Amazon Kindle: The Bookthief? July 25, 2009Posted by cmvlibrarian in Mobile Devices, Reading.
Tags: copyright, ebooks, Kindle
add a comment
Chances are you’ve never had a book retailer break into your home and remove books from your own bookshelf. But something all too similar happened last week to Amazon Kindle users.
The New York Time’s reports that Amazon made use of the Kindle’s wireless capabilities to delete questionable content from users’ devices. Apparently a non-rights holder to George Orwell’s 1984 added the novel as an unauthorized ebook to Amazon’s catalog, which several customers purchased. Amazon suggested the publisher requested the deletions and Amazon simply complied. Amazon said it was sorry and promised never to do it again.
But according to the Associated Press, Amazon changed its story this week, saying it deleted the books after it realized on its own that the books weren’t authorized. Apparently Amazon didn’t need any outside prodding before it took a page out of the Bookthief and yanked the customers’ books from their Kindles (to be fair Amazon did issue refunds for the deleted ebooks). After all the public outcry Amazon’s CEO apologized personally and promised never to do it again.
At this point why should we believe Amazon though? Amazon’s spent a lot of effort and money to convince the public that ebooks were just like physical books only better and less expensive. That was one of the hooks Amazon used to market a pricey device (originally it sold for $400) , but with it’s recent actions Amazon’s proven that’s not the case.
With a physical book, after you’ve paid for it, it’s yours. You could sell it or give it to a friend. But when you buy an ebook you don’t have that right because you’re only buying a license to read the ebook. Now Amazon had promised that the license would be yours indefinitely, but with the ebook deletions Amazon has demonstrated it can revoke the license at anytime.
So what are your options? Chris Walters from the Consumerist has several suggestions. His ideas range from backing up your ebooks off your Kindle to converting file formats.
His best suggestion however, was using a site called Feedbooks. You can download the Feedbooks catalog to your Kindle from their website. Then you can flip through their catalog like an ebook, except you can select books from their catalog to download wirelessly for free. The books are yours to keep. The downside is that even though there’s some recent books available under a Creative Commons license, the vast majority of the books in their catalog are public domain works. In other words you’ll be able to download Huckfin for free but not more recent popular works like Harry Potter.
Seem like your choices are kind of limited? Unfortunately with the way copyright works, they are. Legally speaking Amazon is in the clear. To learn more about copyright law (and some proposed revisions), I recommend the American Library Association’s Copyright section on their website.
The DRM Kindle Lockdown June 28, 2009Posted by cmvlibrarian in Information Sharing, Reading.
add a comment
I can honestly say that I’ve never had a negative experience with my Amazon Kindle. I’ve enjoyed it so much that I blogged about it in a previous post. But I’ve just heard of something that could be a problem to many users in the near future.
Dan Cohen, author of the Gear Diary Blog encountered a series of problems when he tried to sych his Kindle books to his new iPhone. He was basically unable to add several of his books to his new device. When he called Amazon’s customer service center he received a series of conflicting reports. For the full story read Part 1 and Part 2 at his blog.
The final answer the Cohen ended up getting was that publishers limit the number of devices that you can have your Kindle Books on at any give time. When you buy a Kindle book there is currently no information regarding the number of devices you can have it on. While most publishers allow for several devices (which makes sense given you can read the books on the Kindle, iPod touch, and the iPhone) some only allow you to have it on one device.
Every time you upgrade one of those devices the system considers that an extra device, even if you don’t use the former device anymore. So eventually (and with the frequency upgrades these days it may not take too long) you’ll reach a point where you won’t be able to add the books you’ve already PAID for to your device.
Cohen was finally able to have Amazon allow him to download his books for no additional charge but it took talking with several different people, giving him conflicting information before they correctly followed Amazon’s procedure.
Who’s to say that someone else will be able to get a hold of customer service rep that’s familiar with this specific policy or that Amazon won’t at some point change this policy. While I still love the Kindle this is really going to make me leery of upgrading my version 1.0 device anytime soon-no matter how cool future models may be.
Librarian Negotiation 101 June 28, 2009Posted by cmvlibrarian in Conferences, Professional Development.
Tags: SLA 2009 Annual Conference
add a comment
High stakes international diplomacy or corporate takeovers are images most people associate with negotiation. But negotiation can be integral to an information professional’s career as well.
Need some convincing? According to Mary Ellen Bates, president and founder of Bates Information Services, 70% of men make more money than their female colleagues for the same job just because they push back on the first salary offer when taking a new job.
Bates actually gave an impressive presentation on “Painless Negotiation” at the 2009 SLA Annual Conference. Some highlights from Bate’s presentation:
- Remembering you always have choices, even if you don’t like them.
- Use I-statements and speak in terms of what you WANT-not what you think you DESERVE.
- Remember that while negotiation can feel unpleasant, its bigger payoff makes it worth it.
- Try to figure out and address the other party’s concerns before they can raise objections.
Keep in mind that negotiation isn’t limited to wage issues or even only conducted with your supervisor. Most info pros have had to manage a client/patron’s expectations at some point-this is just another form of negotiation. For more tips and strategies on being a successful negotiator, I highly recommend viewing the complete version of the presentation at Bates’s website.
Experience the SLA 2009 Conference via Twitter June 20, 2009Posted by cmvlibrarian in Conferences, Professional Development.
Tags: SLA, SLA 2009 Annual Conference
add a comment
I recently attended the Special Libraries Association’s Centennial Conference. While there I made frequent use of the SLA 2009 twitter group (I was actually the top Twitter poster while there). For anyone that’s ever wondered what a conference is like in real time I’ve reproduced my Twitter feed for the conference below. I’ve added some navigational headers to make the feed easier to read. Enjoy!
Getting Ready for SLA
So what’s the most important thing you want to accomplish at the annual conference? #sla20093:50 PM Jun 11th from mobile web
Just told one of my friends I’m going to a library conference and they said, “Be safe.” Someone’s on to us! #sla20095:28 PM Jun 11th from mobile web
#sla2009 Wonder if they’ll play any Asher Roth at the IT Party?5:04 PM Jun 12th from mobile web
#sla2009 pick up books for parade, pick up jacket from mens wearhouse, last minute MACYS shopping, packing bags, then finally some sleep5:06 PM Jun 12th from mobile web
http://twitpic.com/78qz3 – Dig the new shades for SLA? #sla20098:30 PM Jun 12th from TwitPic
Arriving at SLA
on the metro heading to conference-might miss the 2010 planning session though #sla20091:12 PM Jun 13th from mobile web
#sla2009 made it to the hotel! and it’s nice!!2:10 PM Jun 13th from mobile web
#sla2009 finally found the convention center! whoo is it hot outside.
Capital Pride Parade
eating at the subway by the convention center-prepping for GLBTIC marching in the Pride Parade! #sla20093:20 PM Jun 13th from mobile web
Just checked GLBTIC into the Pride Parade! I’m at the school meet up point-come see me😉 #sla20094:57 PM Jun 13th from mobile web
@yankeeincanada I saw your tweet the others are lining up but im still at the school for you #sla20095:28 PM Jun 13th from mobile web
http://twitpic.com/7bjc0 – Eric did a great job with our GLBTIC banner! #sla20095:33 PM Jun 13th from TwitPic
Manning the DC Chapter’s Hospitality Booth
Well marching in the Capital Pride Parade with GLBTIC was fun-now off to run the DC Chapter Hospitality booth #sla20099:08 AM Jun 14th from web
wow just heard about Gov 2.0 for the first time #sla20099:47 AM Jun 14th from mobile web
Govloop.com sounds like it has potential #sla20099:49 AM Jun 14th from mobile web
LOL the only question I’ve had to answer is how to get to Pentagon city mall #sla200910:31 AM Jun 14th from mobile web
Done with the hospitality booth-who wants lunch? #sla200911:36 AM Jun 14th from mobile web
Lunch and Opening Expo
http://twitpic.com/7dvzw – The hoovers robot rocks! #sla200912:29 PM Jun 14th from TwitPic
Eating at GordonBiersch right across from the Spy Museum #sla20091:18 PM Jun 14th from mobile web
lexis nexus giving away nice bags #sla20094:50 PM Jun 14th from mobile web
Opening Keynote and Awards
yay Janice Lachance!!! Rock on! #sla20095:32 PM Jun 14th from mobile web
special isn’t about being a special librarian but being a human being- steven abram #sla20095:35 PM Jun 14th from mobile web
done guzzeling champagne and heading to spy museum tour! come join me! #sla20098:17 PM Jun 14th from mobile web
just met the editor of Information outlook-he was super nice and wants our feedback! rock on!! #sla20098:33 PM Jun 14th from mobile web
Mary Ellen Bates presenting “Painless (no, really!) Negotiating”
Mary Ellen bates likes using i-statement and says everything is negotiable #sla20099:11 AM Jun 15th from web
you always have choices-not always good ones but there are always alternatives #sla20099:12 AM Jun 15th from web
when you hear something it’s just the first offer #sla20099:13 AM Jun 15th from web
you just have to ask for it #sla20099:13 AM Jun 15th from web
it doesn’t hurt to ask #sla20099:13 AM Jun 15th from web
technical difficulties with power point in our sesssion #sla20099:14 AM Jun 15th from web
put onus for decisions back on the other person #sla20099:16 AM Jun 15th from web
Say I want not I deserve while negotiating to have stronger stance #sla20099:18 AM Jun 15th from web
negotiating is a moment of discomfort to get a larger payoff #sla20099:19 AM Jun 15th from web
70% of men have higher salary than women because they push back on the first salary offer #sla20099:21 AM Jun 15th from web
negotiating doesn’t = confrontation #sla20099:22 AM Jun 15th from web
negotiating is just another conversation where you’re both working towards the same goal #sla20099:23 AM Jun 15th from web
don’t negotiate for your minimum-first offer will be high #sla20099:24 AM Jun 15th from web
if you start at the minimum then you have no place to go down to #sla20099:25 AM Jun 15th from web
you don’t have to be dissatisfied in order to ask for more #sla20099:25 AM Jun 15th from web
the other party really doesn’t care about whether or not you are satisfied #sla20099:26 AM Jun 15th from web
remember this is business not personal-even if you do have a personal relationship with the other party #sla20099:27 AM Jun 15th from web
identify your best outcome #sla20099:27 AM Jun 15th from web
ask yourself tangibly what you want-something that can be measured #sla20099:28 AM Jun 15th from web
id your best alternative to negotiated agreement-this is what happens if the negotiation fails- can u walk away and feel ok? #sla20099:30 AM Jun 15th from web
become the other-identify what the other person wants at the end of the negotiation and what happens to them if talks fail #sla20099:31 AM Jun 15th from web
how can I move what I want forward while still advancing the other party’s interests #sla20099:31 AM Jun 15th from web
you take responsibility for the success of the negotiation #sla20099:33 AM Jun 15th from web
each party takes 100% of the responsibility for the negotiation #sla20099:34 AM Jun 15th from web
MEB has a cute little chart of competing pressures #sla20099:35 AM Jun 15th from web
We should view complimentary pressures instead of competing pressures while negotiating #sla20099:36 AM Jun 15th from web
sounds like shes saying try to find a win-win scenario and how you can get there #sla20099:37 AM Jun 15th from web
be sure to talk about what you WANT not what you NEED #sla20099:38 AM Jun 15th from web
at the end of the convo if you decide to keep the status quo you can at least agree to revisit in a specified amount of time #sla20099:42 AM Jun 15th from web
knowing that you have alternatives gives you a firm base in the negotiation #sla20099:44 AM Jun 15th from web
address each of the other parties goals- how can i get what i want and still meet their goals as well #sla20099:46 AM Jun 15th from web
do you’re homework and find as many options as you can-research and talk to other people to find out whats worked for them #sla20099:47 AM Jun 15th from web
answer their questions before they have a chance to raise their objections #sla20099:47 AM Jun 15th from web
MEB has a nice matrix of her needs and alternatives and goals as well as the other party’s for negotiating #sla20099:52 AM Jun 15th from web
listen to what the other person says #sla20099:52 AM Jun 15th from web
focus on our joint interests and don’t assume #sla20099:54 AM Jun 15th from web
its important to look at what your goal will look like not HOW you get there #sla20099:55 AM Jun 15th from web
aim for what’s possible not for what you’ll settle for #sla20099:55 AM Jun 15th from web
say what’s true for you #sla20099:56 AM Jun 15th from web
you have the right to decide how to live your life #sla20099:56 AM Jun 15th from web
assume any situation is negotiable #sla20099:57 AM Jun 15th from web
move beyond the fear-it’s just a feeling and it goes away #sla20099:58 AM Jun 15th from web
with fear-it’s like you can be hungry and still be doing something else#sla20099:58 AM Jun 15th from web
negotiate from an assumption of abundance #sla20099:59 AM Jun 15th from web
if you come from the assumption that this will work out ok it can shift the way it does come out. #sla200910:00 AM Jun 15th from web
shift from worst case thinking to best case thinking #sla200910:01 AM Jun 15th from web
interest based rather than position bases discussion is a better negotiating method #sla200910:02 AM Jun 15th from web
positions are difficult to move-interests are something you can move towards #sla200910:03 AM Jun 15th from web
go at the problem not each other #sla200910:03 AM Jun 15th from web
in the next week negotiate something you haven’t negotiated before- the Mary Ellen Bates challenge #sla200910:04 AM Jun 15th from web
batesinfo.com/sla2009 has all MEB presentations #sla200910:06 AM Jun 15th from web
a photographer was snapping pictures of me twittering during MEB’s presentation-i wonder how it’ll be used. #sla200910:07 AM Jun 15th from web
so glad I dressed up now😉 #sla200910:08 AM Jun 15th from web
Networking Lunch and Expo
at the networking lunch eating with uber awesome GLBTIC members. Come join us #sla200911:42 AM Jun 15th from mobile web
getting a massage from the inspec station-our vendors rock! #sla20091:17 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
I think the international reception sounds like the place to be tonight #sla20091:18 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
SLA Hot Topic: “Wikis, Tweets, and Blogs, Oh My!”
at the sla hot topic-blogs,wikis and oh my session#sla20091:44 PM Jun 15th from web
so far it sounds like this is about copyright on the web #sla20091:45 PM Jun 15th from web
talking about reforming copyright law concerning orphan works to reduce risk to libraries/users1:46 PM Jun 15th from web
this session isn’t quite what I was expecting. What other sessions are going on right now? #sla20091:47 PM Jun 15th from web
Now their talking about a college student that paid tuition by writing an application for sale on iTunes #sla20091:51 PM Jun 15th from web
Laura Malone Associate General Council for the Associate Press is talking now #sla20091:52 PM Jun 15th from web
“back in the day” it was harder to make a copy of something #sla20091:53 PM Jun 15th from web
“if it’s cool you should let me do it” #sla20091:54 PM Jun 15th from web
“we want to be responsive to the people out there tweeting or twittering-whatever you call it” #1:55 PM Jun 15th from web
Copyright is about encouraging people to create works-we pay them in one form or another so they don’t have to get another job #sla20091:56 PM Jun 15th from web
Sometimes people copy and paste an entire article to share the news-that’s a copyright violation #sla20091:57 PM Jun 15th from web
there’s a difference between a news aggregator and a blogger #sla20091:58 PM Jun 15th from web
the problem we have is when a blogger’s copy and paste news stories to the blog so people don’t go to legitimate news sources #sla20091:59 PM Jun 15th from web
copyright owners have a number of exclusive rights #sla20092:00 PM Jun 15th from web
most choose how their work will be presented and seen #sla20092:00 PM Jun 15th from web
It’s pretty easy to get an inexpensive license to reproduce something #sla20092:01 PM Jun 15th from web
Is video harder to catch copyright violations than text? #sla20092:02 PM Jun 15th from web
AP relies on some software for policing video but mostly rely on people to report violations #sla20092:03 PM Jun 15th from web
AP adds contact info to the cease and desist letters so people that might not know better can become legitimate customers #sla20092:05 PM Jun 15th from web
AP just got 3 new customers that used to violate their copyrights becasue they didn’t realize they were violating anything #sla20092:06 PM Jun 15th from web
Pirate Bay founders were sentenced to a year in Jail over copyright violations #sla20092:07 PM Jun 15th from web
A blogger Jill is speaking now-I missed her last name #sla20092:08 PM Jun 15th from web
Oh it’s the ITs division Jill Hurst-Wahl-I’m all the way in the back tethered to an outlet-my excuse for not recognizing her #sla20092:10 PM Jun 15th from web
Tolerated use is when the author obviously wants you to get the word out and you can recreate the entire post #sla20092:11 PM Jun 15th from web
Jill’s never had a problem with tolerated use #sla20092:11 PM Jun 15th from web
when people copy some of her work to be informative and gives her credit-not really sure whether to go after them #sla20092:13 PM Jun 15th from web
moderator-“information wants to be free, but it also wants to be expensive” #sla20092:13 PM Jun 15th from web
If you retweet me and it cites me I get credit and thats cool if the accreditation falls off at some point . . . that’s cool too #sla20092:16 PM Jun 15th from web
moderator just asked Jill how she decides what to do with tweet and blogs #sla20092:17 PM Jun 15th from web
Jill actually did a blog post of pasted tweets. #sla20092:17 PM Jun 15th from web
55% of twitterers have never twittered and never followed anyone-moderator #sla20092:18 PM Jun 15th from web
wow JIll has over 700 followers! Rock on!! #sla20092:20 PM Jun 15th from web
I follow Jill Hurst as well-her tweets are usually really good #sla20092:20 PM Jun 15th from web
Ok I’m leaving the session now to change clothes and then go the dialog champagne reception in the expo hall #sla20092:22 PM Jun 15th from web
@hoovers still can’t get over Hoovy the robot! bonus points for the piggyback rides he gives #sla20092:31 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
If anyone has material from “Speak as if your career depended on it” can you direct message me please #sla20093:55 PM Jun 15th from web
For all the partiers out there I’ll be at the International Reception 5:30-7 then the Spy Museum Party from 8-11 #sla20093:57 PM Jun 15th from web
Then I’ll finish off the night at the IT Division’s Sci Fi Open house #sla20093:59 PM Jun 15th from web
Thank you Dow Jones and Elsevier for hosting the monday night parties!! You Rock!!! #sla20094:01 PM Jun 15th from web
International Reception hosted by Dow Jones
on my way to the international reception-come join me #sla20095:43 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
wow the line for the international reception to get on the shuttle is super long #sla20096:16 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
Someone just said they became a librarian because they “like books but that’s a pathetic reason” but that’s why I did #sla20096:17 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
yay we made it on the bus! on our way to the reception #sla20096:30 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
Spy Museum Party hosted by Elsevier
on the bus to the spy museum #sla20098:12 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
getting lost on the way to the spy museum #sla20098:33 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
omg thank you elsevier for the spy museum party!! #sla20099:35 PM Jun 15th from mobile web
“Food’s Future Luncheon” Joan Leake speaking
I missed my 7am session so I’m looking for something to do until the Food’s Future luncheon #sla200910:45 AM Jun 16th from web
at food’s future staring at a salad #sla200911:23 AM Jun 16th from mobile web
People buying less meat with the recession #sla200911:50 AM Jun 16th from mobile web
People like authentic ethnic food #sla200911:51 AM Jun 16th from mobile web
people are eating more salt than ever #sla200911:52 AM Jun 16th from mobile web
local foods are beginning to look like a better option over organic #sla200911:54 AM Jun 16th from mobile web
GLBTIC Business Meeting
Getting ready for the GLBTIC business meeting. This is my first one facilitating in SLA-should be fun #sla200912:34 PM Jun 16th from mobile web
Come to the GLBTIC business meeting to network and hear Charles Francis speak about the Kameny Papers Project #sla200912:36 PM Jun 16th from mobile web
Introducing ourselves at the GLBTIC meeting #sla20091:36 PM Jun 16th from web
FYI GLBTICer Mary Ellen Bates is running for election in SLA rock on! #sla20091:39 PM Jun 16th from web
Charles Francis’s presentation to GLBTIC “Archive Activism”
Charles Francis is speaking about the Kameny Papers Project #sla20092:13 PM Jun 16th from web
Frank Kamey is “sort of our Rosa Parks” #sla20092:14 PM Jun 16th from web
Saving documents is an act of activism #sla20092:15 PM Jun 16th from web
We think of history as text . . . rarely do we think of history something as we have to rescue #sla20092:16 PM Jun 16th from web
Thousands of LGBT books were burned in 1933 Nazi Germany, and it was the largest collection of its time #sla20092:18 PM Jun 16th from web
The story of the Kameny Papers is a miracle itself since the collection survived the years.2:19 PM Jun 16th from web
Kameny was fired from the federal government in 1956 because he was gay #sla20092:19 PM Jun 16th from web
Just pased out a document called “Blackmailer at the work in Dupont Circle Area” #sla20092:21 PM Jun 16th from web
He’s got the formal letter written to Kameny from the Civil Service collection about why gays couldn’t work in federal government #sla20092:23 PM Jun 16th from web
Kameny organized the first LGBT White House Picketting in the 1960s #sla20092:25 PM Jun 16th from web
Thanks to this collection there is now a comparison market for LGBT archival material #sla20092:26 PM Jun 16th from web
Letter from John Hanes Jr., about why the government wouldn’t rehire Kameny because he was gay #sla20092:28 PM Jun 16th from web
Letter says that homosexuals are “security risks” and are “disruptive in any organization” #sla20092:29 PM Jun 16th from web
This letter is now on display in the Library of Congress as part of the collection #sla20092:30 PM Jun 16th from web
In 2006 the Library of Congress had no openly LGBT collection but the LOC saw the value in the Kameny Archive. #sla20092:31 PM Jun 16th from web
All the papers are available to the public in the manuscript reading room #sla20092:32 PM Jun 16th from web
There are plans for a private LGBT Museum here in Washington DC!!!! #sla20092:34 PM Jun 16th from web
There are picket signs from the White House Picketing in the Smithsonian alongside Thomas Jefferson’s lap desk #sla20092:36 PM Jun 16th from web
The archive was paid for by raising money from the gay community to meet the appraised value #sla20092:39 PM Jun 16th from web
Very important to get the word out so people can view the collection because that’s how the library measures its success #sla20092:41 PM Jun 16th from web
http://www.kamenypapers.org is the official website for the project and has some samples of the collection #sla20092:42 PM Jun 16th from web
It took the LOC a year and a half to index the collection #sla20092:43 PM Jun 16th from web
How do you decide which materials are of historical value for an archive? #sla20092:44 PM Jun 16th from web
Frank Kamney is 84 lives in DC, he just rode in the lead car in the Capital Pride Parade. #sla20092:47 PM Jun 16th from web
He actually appealed his firing all the way to the Supreme Court! #sla20092:47 PM Jun 16th from web
He stormed a Psychiatry conference and told all the attendees that “they are the problem not us” #sla20092:49 PM Jun 16th from web
Kameny’s house is actually registered as an historical landmark. #sla20092:52 PM Jun 16th from web
The LOC paid for the curation of the archive 100% #sla20092:54 PM Jun 16th from web
The collection covers about 1957-1970s for the most part #sla20092:57 PM Jun 16th from web
http://twitpic.com/7k9a8 – One of the letters in the Kameny Papers #sla20093:21 PM Jun 16th from TwitPic
Expo and GLBTIC Annual Dinner and Stars Bistro and Bar
at the fastcase booth checking out a twitter feed #sla20094:08 PM Jun 16th from mobile web
At the GLBTIC Dinner in Stars Bistro and Bar-come join us! It’ll be a gay old time #sla20097:02 PM Jun 16th from mobile web
kind of sad no singing waiters tonight-but still having a lot of fun #sla20097:55 PM Jun 16th from mobile web
http://twitpic.com/7l585 – Another reason to be at the GLBTIC Dinner #sla20099:21 PM Jun 16th from TwitPic
IT Dance Party and after hours in Chinatown
IT Party!!! #sla20099:53 PM Jun 16th from mobile web
closing out the night in chinatown with a few librarians #sla200912:49 AM Jun 17th from mobile web
Bouncer has to throw librarians out of the bar because we love to party #sla20091:37 AM Jun 17th from mobile web
Leaving the Conference
Heading home thank you SLA leaders and staff for an amazing conference. See everyone in 2010! #sla200910:54 AM Jun 17th from mobile web
yay! I went to grab a drink right as the SLA tour group was going through my area #sla20093:31 PM Jun 18th from web
Yelp-ing with pleasure February 7, 2009Posted by cmvlibrarian in Information Sharing, Web 2.0.
add a comment
Yelp has been around for awhile so I was hesitant to blog about until something happened to me, twice actually. For those of you, who haven’t used Yelp its own about page does a really good job of summing it up:
Yelp is the fun and easy way to find, review and talk about what’s great (and not so great) in your world. You already know that asking friends is the best way to find restaurants, dentists, hairstylists, and anything local. Yelp makes it fast and easy by collecting and organizing your friends’ recommendations in one convenient place.
I’ve only been Yelping since the 2008 SLA Annual Conference, where a number of professionals that travel often recommended it when in an unfamiliar area. Since then I’ve added about 14 reviews to it; I’ve even been the first to review a few businesses.
A few months ago I went to my local barber to get my regular hair cut. The owner surprised me by telling me she’d seen my Yelp review. They normally do an outstanding job at this barber shop but to my surprise the owner went all out and gave me even better treatment than I normally get. This is turn prompted me to return to Yelp and give the barbershop and even higher rating. I didn’t really think about it again (except for on hair cut days), until today when I went to FaceLogic. I’d was the first to rate them on Yelp a few months prior and left a glowing review. Sometime in the last month they’d come across my review, so today not only did they go the extra mile during my visit but they gave me bonus loyalty points (which can be cashed in for discounts). Again I went to Yelp and raised my rating for them.
That’s when it struck me that Yelp has worked out a uniquely empowering system. All this time I thought I’d just been sharing information about local resources with other people (what information professional wouldn’t love that?), but the truth is Yelp goes far beyond that. What I was really doing was expressing myself around a brand, and forming and even deeper recipracol relationship with the businesses. There’s the potential for a Yelp user to form the kind of relationship with businesses that a professional critic for a newspaper or magazine might achieve.
Wikipedia vs Google grudge match July 31, 2008Posted by cmvlibrarian in Information Sharing, Web 2.0.
Tags: Google Knol, Wikipedia
add a comment
According to Google a Knol “is an an authoritative article about a specific topic”. This sounds surprisingly similar to a Wikipedia article, however there are some major differences:
- Most Knols only have one author
- Google registration is required and author’s name as well as any credentials are prominently displayed
- Users can rate Knols and the aggregate rating is prominently displayed
So Google’s set up a system where some topics are likely to have several different articles that can be screened by users easily via the author’s credentials and the article’s rating. This kind of system is likely to attract people who were turned off to Wikipedia due to disputes over content, as well as people looking to increase their name recognition in a particular field.
While Wikipedia currently trumps Google Knol in sheer number of articles (particularly those relating to pop culture) having to create a Google account seems a small constraint given the Web giant’s ubiquity. Still the critical factor in Google Knol’s success is going to be the quality of articles.
To compare article quality I examined the general HIV article from Wikipedia and the highest rated HIV article from Google Knol by Rick Hecht, a doctor in San Francisco (a search for HIV resulted in 10 Knols of varying quality). Both articles were of decent length, included a number of authoritative references, were organized according to a hyperlinked table of contents, discussed clinical and historical information about HIV, and linked to statistical information from UNAIDS. However some notable differences included:
- The Knol was written more informally and was easier for a laymen to understand
- The images in the Knol were incorporated into the article more efficiently to enhance clarity
- Wikipedia’s article linked to a variety of related material and topics to encourage exploration
- The references in the Wikipedia article were hyperlinked making their quality faster to evaluate
Despite the hype I’d say Google Knol is a promising complimentary platform to Wikipedia rather than a knock out blow to it. With Google Knol researchers new to a topic can quickly filter for higher quality material and evaluate controversial topics by reading multiple articles on the same topic from different points of view. Wikipedia’s more likely to have material of interest because of sheer number of articles and researchers are more likely to discover new information through serendipity. In short don’t count Wikipedia out yet but definitely add Google Knol to your research utility belt.
Creating A-Z Indexes for Websites or Intranets July 18, 2008Posted by cmvlibrarian in Cataloging, Web productivity.
Tags: Click U, SLA, SLA WAshington DC Chapter
add a comment
Heather Hedden of Viziant Corporation Principal facilitated an informative Click U session on how websites and intranets can benefit from A-Z indexes.
First Hedden differentiated indexes from sitemaps. Though somewhat related sitemaps show users how a website is structured like a book’s table of contents while indexes guide users to key content/concepts. So while sitemaps might aid navigation it’s site indexes that can enhance site searching.
Given the effort and complexities that go into making A-Z indexes Hedden recommended that they be used for content not likely to be changed often and for small to medium size websites (about up to a few hundred pages). She also recommended double posting multiple synonyms unless it was important to educate users about a certain terminology in which case “See” notations are justified.
Hedden also described some of the strengths and weaknesses of two automated web indexing tools. XRefHT might benefit organizations with smaller budgets since it’s freeware. An alternative with stronger term editing features available for purchase is HTML Indexer. Using either of these tools can help librarians create fairly complex indexes without having to know any actual HTML or CSS.